Buck compton breaking8/17/2023 You really weirdly fail to credit this as historical research. If let's say he used the interviews with Easy in combination with sourcing information that was unknown to any other historian, shedding new light onto a topic, then I would consider him to be a historian. This includes interviews with eyewitnesses, but also includes study of historical archives. Ambrose positions himself as someone who does a lot of primary source research. He pieces together accounts of primary sources distilled through trained eyes (a.k.a. storytellers way too far.ĭan Carlin does not identify as a historian because he does zero primary source research. Not knowing what specific "definition" you reference but understanding his general deference to historical sources and historians, I think you're taking his emphasis on identifying historians vs. I've listened to a dozen or so episodes of Dan Carlin's podcast. Great series with great production value, and a really compelling story. I've seen better history written by journalists.Īmbrose has been thoroughly discredited in the historian community for writing an Eisenhower biography based on a deep friendship and thousands of hours of contact with a man he in reality only spoke to for three hours, max. This is far from Ambrose's only inaccuracy. That's what happens when a historian just takes grandpa's stories at face value without doing any actual historical work or analysis. They portrayed Buck Compton super well when he reached a breaking point, but simply because Dike was an E Co outsider, he was treated as some sort of war-dodging coward. He wasn't just some coward that couldn't take combat. Additionally, in Dike's involvement in this attack, he was actually seriously wounded when he took cover and the attack got bogged down. Ambrose failed to do any additional research of his own and present a fair picture of Dike, as is a historian's job. Dike was spoken of very poorly by E Co veterans, but in reality he was a decorated soldier in his other service. Gonna take this opportunity to preach since others are praising the miniseries.Īmbrose is a poor historian and it is probably best treat the mini-series as a Hollywood dramatization of real events.įor an easy example, this very scene. Website | Twitter | Facebook | Instagram | Flickr | Snapchat | Google Plus | YouTube | DugoutĪrsenalist | /u/AriesArsenal Match Highlights | /u/AriesArsenal Player HighlightsĬlub History | Chants | Team Photographers | Player Tweets | Player Snapchats Next game in: 44 days 1 hours 54 minutes r/ArsenalWFC | /r/GunnersAtGames | /r/FootballDownload | /r/FootballHighlights | /r/Soccer | /r/PremierLeague | /r/SoccerStreams | FAQs | Match Thread Guide | Fantasy H2H: 3482486-797510 Powered by /u/eabryt and /u/BenjaniMaples His wife Donna passed away in 1994.Frequently Asked Questions Community Guidelines Match Thread Information Request Match Thread Bot /r/Gunners Discord Server Transfer Rumour Guide FantasyPL Code: qg48ra He was in ROTC at UCLA and became an active serviceman in February 1943.Ĭompton is survived by two daughters and four grandchildren. He was a basketball and football star at UCLA, playing in the 1943 Rose Bowl. Lynn Compton was born in Los Angeles on Dec. Governor Ronald Reagan appointed Compton to California’s 2nd District Court of Appeals in 1970, where he was known for his conservative views. Kennedy at the Ambassador Hotel on June 5, 1968, just as the senator learned he had won the California Democratic presidential primary. His most famous case was the successful prosecution of Sirhan Sirhan for the assassination of Robert F. We’re celebrating longevity more than anything.”Ĭompton won a Purple Heart and a Silver Star for his service.Īfter World War II, Compton joined the Los Angeles Police Department and attended Loyola Law School at night. “We didn’t expect anything more than those other guys. Compton said he was flattered and embarrassed by the attention. The actor said he spoke with Compton for hours on end during filming to get the details right and he was so impressed by the man that he nicknamed his son Morgan “Buck.” McDonough and three other stars of the show attended Compton’s 90th birthday party in January.Īfter the mini-series the still-living veterans of Easy Company became mini-celebrities in their own right. Compton was winningly portrayed by Neal McDonough ( Boomtown, Justified) as a good soldier and inspiring leader.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |